diff --git a/_meta/decision-log.md b/_meta/decision-log.md index fda215a..3564733 100644 --- a/_meta/decision-log.md +++ b/_meta/decision-log.md @@ -26,4 +26,64 @@ Records key architectural decisions for the Personal Agent OS. **Result:** Working brief in <5 minutes, zero API costs, reliable data every tick. -**Cron job ID:** e94447937052 \ No newline at end of file +**Cron job ID:** e94447937052 +## 2026-07-12: GitHub Excluded from AI News Daily Feed + +**Decision:** GitHub repos are excluded from the AI News Daily site feed (`generate_from_athena.py`). Athena still ingests them into `oracle.db` for research; the site generator filters them out. + +**Rationale:** +- GitHub entries (repo releases, model cards) are tool announcements, not news events +- They dominated the feed due to high star-velocity scores (GLM-5.2, DeepSeek-R1, etc.) +- A "Breaking" tag on a repo release violates the editorial rule: repos/papers are never breaking +- GitHub was silently reappearing in the feed at least once this week despite prior exclusion — root cause not conclusively identified (possibly a reverted patch, config drift, or manual override) + +**Implementation:** `generate_from_athena.py` filters `source IN ('github', 'gitlab', 'huggingface', 'arxiv')` → renders as plain links or drops entirely. This is a runtime filter, not a pipeline-level exclusion — Athena's DB still has the data. + +**Trade-offs accepted:** +- Some genuinely interesting repos won't appear on the site (acceptable — site is for news, not discovery) +- If GitHub exclusion is ever reversed, it requires an explicit commit + decision-log entry, not an ad-hoc patch + +**Trade-offs accepted:** +- Root cause of the silent revert is not conclusively identified; this entry documents the symptom and the fix, not a proven cause + +## 2026-07-12: Score-Floor Tiering Replaces Percentile Gates + +**Decision:** AI News Daily tiering (breaking/update/normal) uses absolute score floors + rank, not percentile cutoffs. A tier is allowed to be empty if nothing qualifies. + +**Rationale:** +- Previous system: `BREAKING_PCT = 0.90` (top 10%), `UPDATE_PCT = 0.75` (next 25%) — this guaranteed something always appeared in each tier regardless of quality +- Result: 6 red + 15 green items in a single run because rank alone forced items into tiers +- New system: `min_score` floor per tier; if nothing clears the bar, the tier is empty +- Tiers must reflect editorial quality, not statistical inevitability + +**Implementation:** `config.yaml` defines `tiering.breaking.min_score` and `tiering.update.min_score`. Generator script reads these at runtime. Floors set from real score distribution analysis (see score distribution in oracle.db). + +**Trade-offs accepted:** +- Some runs may have zero "Breaking" items — this is correct behavior, not a bug +- Score floors require periodic review as the score distribution evolves + +## 2026-07-12: "UPDATE" Text Label Dropped (Color-Only for Tier 2) + +**Decision:** Tier 2 (update) items render in green (`#34a83d`) without a "UPDATE | " text prefix. Breaking items retain "Breaking | " prefix. + +**Rationale:** +- "UPDATE | " prefix was visually noisy and implied a correction/follow-up relationship that doesn't exist for most tier-2 items +- Green color alone provides sufficient visual distinction from normal (black) and breaking (red) +- Pending a real replacement label if one emerges from editorial review + +**Trade-offs accepted:** +- Without a text label, tier-2 distinction is color-only (accessibility trade-off, acceptable for this audience) + +## 2026-07-12: Headline Cap Raised to 300 (Ceiling, Not Target) + +**Decision:** `MAX_ITEMS` raised from 40 to 300. This is a hard ceiling, not a target — actual count drops via decay, score floors, and source filtering. + +**Rationale:** +- Previous cap of 40 was arbitrary and too low for a 24h freshness window +- The real constraint is quality (score floor), not count +- 300 provides headroom for high-signal days while preventing runaway output +- Stories that don't meet the score floor are dropped regardless of count + +**Trade-offs accepted:** +- A very high-signal day could theoretically produce 100+ items — editorial review needed if this happens regularly +- The cap is a safety valve, not a design target